Real history behind HBO’s ‘Plot Against America’


The new HBO show based on Philip Roth‘s novel “The Plot Against America,” helmed by David Simon, the Jewish creator of “The Wire,” has made a splash with critics and fans.

The eerily captivating series, which borrows details from the iconic Jewish author’s life and a crucial moment in American history, depicts an alternative reality in which isolationist Charles Lindbergh defeats FDR in the 1940 presidential election and encourages anti-Semitic attitudes throughout the country.

The story follows the Jewish Levin family — young Philip, his brother Sandy and his parents, Bess and Herman — caught in an America that’s veering toward fascism, where anti-Semitism has become mainstream and commonplace.

While “The Plot Against America” is a work of fiction, it features many real newsreels from the period and involves several true stories. Let’s separate fact from fiction and explore the real historical figures and events behind “The Plot Against America,” with some help from the JTA archive.

Charles Lindbergh was a decorated U.S. aviator, writer, activist and, sadly, anti-Semite.

In 1927, the 25-year-old Air Mail pilot from Detroit rose to fame when he flew the first nonstop solo trans-Atlantic flight. “Lucky Lindy” became an American icon following the flight and crowds greeted him wherever he went. His autobiographical tale about his flight, “WE,” became a bestseller and President Calvin Coolidge awarded him the Distinguished Flying Cross medal. A statue of his likeness was erected in Maryland — ironically by a Jewish sculptor, Louis Rosenthal.

The kidnapping of his 20-month-old baby in 1932 was a huge story. Lindbergh paid the ransom, but his son was found dead.

Lindbergh used his fame to promote the young field of aviation around the world. But he also became a leader of the America First movement.

As Uriel Heilman wrote for JTA in 2016: “Created in 1940 after Hitler already had invaded Poland, the America First Committee argued that the U.S. should take a neutral approach toward Nazi Germany, and even do business with it, because the Nazi regime did not threaten America directly.”

Donald Trump was criticized for his frequent use of the phrase “America first” during his presidential campaign.

Was he anti-Semitic?

Lindbergh’s words suggest that he was both a white supremacist and an anti-Semite.

Lindbergh, son of Scandinavian immigrants, was a believer in eugenics. He also believed Germany had a “Jewish problem,” and the influence of Jews in society should be limited. He was close friends with Henry Ford, another known anti-Semite. He wrote in 1939 that American must “preserve that most priceless possession, our inheritance of European blood, only so long as we guard ourselves against attack by foreign armies and dilution by foreign races.”

Did he really give that rousing anti-Semitic speech?

In the first episode of “The Plot Against America,” Herman Levin hears a Lindbergh speech on the radio full of anti-Semitism.

The “greatest danger to this country lies in their [the Jews’] large ownership and influence in our motion pictures, our press, our radio and our government,” Lindbergh said, among other things. Infuriated, Herman calls over his wife, Bess, and says, “He’s calling us war agitators.”

The answer is yes: The excerpts played in the show come from a real speech that Lindbergh delivered in Des Moines on Sept. 11, 1941. But while in “The Plot Against America” the public embraces Lindbergh’s speech, in reality his words were met with an outcry from across the country. “The voice is Lindbergh’s but the words are the words of Hitler,” one major newspaper wrote.

Did he really run for president?

No — but that idea is not simply a product of Roth’s imagination. In 2000, when Roth was reading an autobiography of the historian Arthur Schlesinger Jr., he “came upon a sentence in which Schlesinger notes that there were some Republican isolationists who wanted to run Lindbergh for president in 1940,” Roth told the New York Times. “That’s all there was, that one sentence,” Roth said, “It made me think, ‘What if they had?’”

Is a poll in “The Plot” about attitudes toward Jews real?

At another point in the first episode, a Jewish newsreel projector tells Herman about a 1939 poll in which “Only thirty-nine percent of the respondents agreed that Jews should be treated like everyone else. Fifty-three percent believed that ‘Jews are different and should be restricted.’ And ten percent believed that Jews should be deported.” Sadly, that was a real Roper Poll from that year.

Was Lindbergh really a friend of Hitler’s?

No, but in 1938 he was awarded the Service Cross of the German Eagle by Hermann Goering on behalf of Hitler. Lindbergh also had contacts in the Nazi Foreign Ministry.

As JTA reported in 1962, “in a communication marked ‘most urgent and top secret’,” the Nazis told the German Foreign Ministry and the German chief of general staff that “Lindbergh represents the best of the Americans, who are most important for us now and in the future. The contacts with him are maintained through a group in the general staff which has the greatest importance as a counterweight against Jews and warmongers.”

Did Philip Roth grow up in a suburb of New Jersey?

Yes, Roth grew up in the Weequahic neighborhood of Newark, just like the Levins in the TV series.

His dad’s name also was Herman, his mother, Elizabeth, also went by the moniker Bess, and his older brother, Sanford, went by the nickname Sandy. And just a reminder, the littlest Levin in the show is named Philip. Roth was born in 1933 — that would have made him 7 years old during the 1940 election.

Just like Sandy in the book and series, Roth’s real brother was a gifted artist. And just like the TV father, Roth’s real dad was an insurance salesman. 

Was anti-Semitism really a part of Roth’s childhood?

“Even before I started school,” Roth told the New York Times the year “The Plot Against America” came out, “I already knew something about Nazi anti-Semitism and about the American anti-Semitism that was being stoked, one way or another, by eminent figures like Henry Ford and Charles Lindbergh, who, in those years, along with movie stars like Chaplin and Valentino, were among the most famous international celebrities of the century.”